Read the critics and take your choice - Temporada Canberra's restaurant of the year or a tragic example of the downstream effects of too little training?

There's a reason for this little

restaurant reviews button at the top of our pages. We are starting to index reviews and in time we hope to provide enough material for people to find a critic's review of places they have already been to. That should help our readers make up their own mind about whether the new place being raved about by an "expert" is going to appeal to them or not.
Consider these two conflicting comments below that have appeared in major newspapers this month. Now I have not been to Temporada myself but I am mightily confused about whether I should. Who to take notice of? The Australian's John Lethlean or Natasha Rudra of the Canberra Times?

Perhaps the table showing how all the critics rank Canberra restaurants will help you if you have a similar problem